Blog by Climate Action Network International
COP31 halfway: Deals that protect people sidelined as presidencies chase headlines
COP31 opened with a swiftly agreed agenda and real hope that Antalya could turn the commitments made in Belém into agreements that change lives. Halfway through, that promise is slipping away.
Governments came to Türkiye while wars, genocide and rising living costs deepen distrust in international cooperation. As people around the world endure escalating heat, floods, fires and storms, they are taking to the streets and asking why there is money for weapons and fossil fuel subsidies but not for their protection. COP31 is a chance to show that multilateralism can still deliver for them, yet the gap between their reality and these negotiating rooms has never looked wider.
Political attention is being sucked into discussions about a possible cover decision, an overarching political declaration that governments have not even agreed they need. Developing countries, with the smallest delegations and the most at stake, are having to divert negotiators into those discussions and away from the talks on Just Transition, Adaptation and finance that matter most to them. Meanwhile, Türkiye is promoting its vague headline electrification initiative, and the texts that could deliver practical support to people are being weakened.
Australia stepped forward to steer this COP at a critical moment, with climate minister Chris Bowen as President of Negotiations. But it has yet to show the leadership that moment demands, leaving the talks drifting while the hardest questions go unanswered.
Just Transition: Starting from a low point
As people struggle with rising living costs and uncertain employment, COP31 must establish the Just Transition Mechanism that governments agreed to develop in Belém last year, which civil society is calling the Belém-Antalya Mechanism (BAM). Talks opened with real promise, as G77 countries rallied behind the kind of mechanism civil society has called for and the EU showed new flexibility on finance. But the first negotiating text, due at noon on Friday and not released until midnight, was weakened along the way.
On what the mechanism will actually do, the text offers only the least ambitious options: a website, an annual meeting and a compilation of reports. It would neither help countries access existing funding nor support them in raising more money, improving its quality or tracking where it goes. Proposals that parties raised in the room, including a resource mobilisation task force, do not even appear as options. With the Just Transition talks drawing little public attention, the EU, Norway, Japan and Canada have been able to push down ambition at no political cost. The risk now is a mechanism in name only, with no teeth to deliver.
A text that the least ambitious countries could have signed on day one is not a starting point for negotiations. It is the end point they wanted. In week two, governments must put back what was stripped out: a mechanism that mobilises more and better finance and gives workers, young people and communities a real say in their future, not an empty administrative shell.
Adaptation: Developed countries put the tripling promise at risk
One of the most important commitments from COP30 is now under threat. The promise to triple Adaptation finance remains in the latest Global Goal on Adaptation text, but wealthy countries are resisting it. Australia has opposed its inclusion, despite steering the talks. The EU, Japan and Norway have also objected to references to tripling.
Instead of agreeing how to deliver the finance already pledged, governments are considering further workshops that could push decisions beyond Antalya. For communities facing devastating floods, droughts and failing harvests, every delay means more lives and livelihoods at risk. Tripling also needs an agreed baseline. In Glasgow, developed countries promised to double Adaptation finance with no starting point, and counted almost anything towards it. Without public, grant-based finance, the most debt-distressed countries are left borrowing to protect themselves from a crisis they did not cause.
COP31 must defend the tripling commitment as the floor for a new goal based on real needs, and agree how the money will reach the people who need it.
Loss and damage: A fund far too small for the disasters it faces
In total, 119 countries have asked the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage for USD 2.8 billion, yet it has received only around USD 600 million. Despite that gap, the draft texts in Antalya include an option to give the Fund no guidance at all.
Developing countries want clear direction on how the Fund will be replenished, made more accessible and governed transparently. The EU, Japan, Canada, New Zealand and Norway argue that detailed guidance would interfere with the work of the Fund’s Board. Countries are also split over speeding up replenishment: least developed countries point out that demand far outstrips the money available, while the EU says the process is already under way.
COP31 must give the Fund clear guidance, speed up its replenishment and get grant-based finance to communities when disaster strikes.
Mitigation: The only negotiating track on cutting emissions is stalling
The Mitigation Work Programme, the UN climate talks’ dedicated programme for accelerating emissions cuts this decade, is due to end at COP31. After a week of negotiations, governments are still divided over its future. The Arab Group, the African Group and Malaysia want it to continue until 2030, while the EU and Mongolia have proposed 2040, and parties disagree over how closely it should be tied to the Global Stocktake. What none of them has yet agreed is how it would actually make countries cut harder and sooner.
With the world on the verge of breaching 1.5°C, COP31 must extend and strengthen the Mitigation Work Programme to 2030, turning it into a driver of faster emissions cuts that holds countries to account.
Electrification: A headline in search of justice
Türkiye is promoting its flagship 35×35 initiative, which aims to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. But it says too little about how to make electrification fair. Some 600 million people in Africa still lack electricity, yet they barely feature in a plan that risks powering data centres and air conditioning in the rich world, concerns sharpened by Türkiye’s new AI declaration. Meanwhile, some cover-decision proposals leave room for gas and nuclear. Electrification must pass three tests: it must replace fossil fuels and not include nuclear, run on renewable energy and come with finance for the countries that need it.
More countries are bringing forward national roadmaps for transitioning away from fossil fuels, with further announcements expected in the coming days. That momentum must become real plans, with finance and safeguards for workers and communities.
More electricity is not climate progress if it’s still powered by fossil fuels and nuclear. COP31 must make sure fair electrification drives a just transition away from fossil fuels, backed by public finance, rather than becoming a headline that stands in for the harder work of transforming energy systems.
Climate finance: The answer beneath every question
New text under the Climate Finance Work Programme has reopened old fault lines: developed countries’ obligations under Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement, who should contribute, and how the new climate finance goal will be put into practice. Developing countries are pressing for a delivery target and an agreed baseline, so that commitments can be measured and governments held to account. Countries including the G77 and China rejected the latest text on Saturday as too weak. Meanwhile, wealthy countries are promoting access-to-finance declarations and private finance initiatives that distract from a simpler truth: there is little new public money to access. Climate finance pledges have fallen by 70%, according to Carbon Brief analysis, even as the same governments raise military spending and keep subsidising fossil fuels.
Promises don’t protect people. Finance does. Without public finance from the historic polluters most responsible for the climate crisis, every other outcome risks becoming a plan with no means to carry it out.
COP31 must make real progress on wealthy countries’ duty to provide finance, rather than revisit debates that have delayed action for years.
The Presidencies and the cover decision: Leadership is missing where it matters
Governments remain divided over whether COP31 needs a cover decision, with a first draft expected early this week. Such a decision could matter if it faces up to the world overshooting 1.5°C, commits governments to faster emissions cuts now and secures finance from developed countries for the countries that need it. But no declaration can make up for failing to agree a working Just Transition mechanism and tripled Adaptation finance in the negotiating rooms.
As President of Negotiations, Australia arrived without momentum and has yet to show how it will land this COP’s major agreements. At the Leaders’ Summit, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced no new climate finance and made no mention of fossil fuels, while leaders from several of the world’s wealthiest countries stayed away altogether. As the world’s third-largest fossil fuel exporter, Australia has said nothing about how it will take forward the roadmaps for transitioning away from fossil fuels, and its silence can be read as a lack of will.
More than 60 civil society organisations have sent an open letter to Chris Bowen urging Australia to use its role to lift ambition in week two. They call for a Just Transition mechanism that works, a credible plan to deliver tripled Adaptation finance, a Climate Finance Work Programme focused on developed countries’ obligations, and a clear path for the fossil fuel roadmaps.
COP31’s presidencies must stop chasing headlines and start delivering in the negotiations.
What week two must deliver
As the talks move into their political phase, with the hardest questions still open, governments must agree:
- A Belém-Antalya Mechanism with the functions, resources and meaningful participation needed to support workers, young people and communities.
- A firm commitment to triple Adaptation finance, protected in the final Global Goal on Adaptation outcome, with a credible pathway to delivery.
- Clear guidance to the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage and a faster replenishment, so grant-based finance reaches vulnerable communities quickly.
- An extended and strengthened Mitigation Work Programme that speeds up emissions cuts this decade.
- A transition away from fossil fuels that fair electrification strengthens rather than replaces.
- Clear targets for developed countries’ public climate finance obligations, with accountability for meeting them.
The test for Antalya is not what governments announce, but whether they agree on outcomes that protect people’s lives and livelihoods.
This article has been sourced from the official website of Climate Action Network International and can be accessed here. It has been slightly edited.